Buying running shoes can feel weirdly high-stakes. There are hundreds of models, every brand has its own jargon, and it’s easy to get pulled into “best shoe” lists that don’t match your body or how you actually run.
A better way to think about it is this: the best running shoe is simply the one that helps you run comfortably, consistently, and injury-free. The right pair won’t magically make you faster, but the wrong pair can make every run feel harder than it needs to.
Here’s how to choose well, without overcomplicating it.
Start with the only three things that really matter
Most running shoes are variations on a theme. When you strip away the marketing, your decision comes down to three questions:
- Does it fit properly?
- Does it feel comfortable at running pace?
- Does it suit the kind of running you do most?
If a shoe nails those three, the rest is detail.
Fit comes first because even the “best” shoe is useless if it rubs, pinches, or lets your foot slide around. Comfort matters because you’re going to take thousands of steps in these; you shouldn’t be trying to “break them in” through pain. And the ride matters because the same shoe can feel great for easy miles and awful for faster work (or vice versa).
Get the fit right before you think about anything else
A running shoe should feel secure without feeling tight. The heel should stay put, the midfoot should feel supported, and your toes should have room to spread.
A simple check: when you stand up in the shoes, you should generally have about a thumbnail’s width of space in front of your longest toe. Too little space is a fast track to black toenails and hotspots, especially as your feet swell on longer runs.
Toe box width matters as much as length. If your toes feel squeezed together in the shop, they’ll feel worse 30 minutes into a run. Conversely, if the front of the shoe feels roomy but your foot slides forward when you run, you’ll end up with friction. You’re aiming for “room to move” without “room to slosh.”
One underrated tip: try shoes on later in the day if you can. Feet tend to be slightly bigger then, which makes your sizing more realistic.
Don’t buy a shoe just because you “need support”
A lot of runners assume they must buy stability shoes if they “overpronate,” or neutral shoes if they don’t. In practice, it’s rarely that clean.
Stability shoes can be helpful if you feel like you’re collapsing inward and you consistently do better with a guided, supportive feel. Neutral shoes can be great if you like a more natural ride and don’t need that guidance. But you don’t want a shoe that fights your movement, you want one that supports it.
If you’re unsure, a good running shop can be genuinely useful here. Not because you need a perfect “gait diagnosis,” but because trying a few options back-to-back (neutral and stability, different brands, different shapes) quickly tells you what your body likes.
Choose cushioning based on what you’ll actually use the shoe for
Cushioning isn’t “good” or “bad”, it’s preference plus purpose.
If most of your running is easy, steady mileage, you’ll probably appreciate a shoe with enough cushioning to feel comfortable day after day. If you like speed sessions or want something snappier, you may prefer a lighter, more responsive feel. And if you run on tired legs a lot (or you’re returning from time off), extra cushioning can simply make running feel more inviting.
The mistake is assuming softer automatically means safer. A very soft shoe can feel lovely, but it can also feel unstable or “sinky” for some runners. Ideally, the shoe feels comfortable and predictable underfoot.
Pay attention to the “ride,” not just how it feels standing still
A shoe can feel great the moment you step into it and still feel wrong once you start running. When you test jog, notice whether the shoe rolls you forward smoothly, whether it feels clunky, and whether you feel like you’re fighting it.
Also consider your typical pace. Some shoes feel amazing when you’re jogging easy and dull when you pick it up. Others feel a bit firm at slow speeds but come alive when you run faster. Neither is wrong it’s about matching the shoe to your training.
This is where online shopping can be tricky. If you do buy online, choose retailers with a proper trial/return policy and keep the box until you’re sure.
Road vs trail vs “a bit of both”
If you mostly run on roads and pavements, a road shoe is usually the best option: lighter, smoother ride, and less aggressive underfoot.
Trail shoes are built for grip and durability, which is great on mud, rocks, and uneven ground, but those same features can feel heavy or stiff on tarmac. If you genuinely do both, you can either pick one “hybrid” style shoe or accept that owning two pairs (one road, one trail) makes life easier.
Common mistakes to avoid
Most shoe-buying mistakes come from rushing or chasing trends.
Buying for looks is obvious, but so is buying because an elite runner wears them or because a model is “the best” in a roundup. The best shoe for you is the one that fits your foot shape and suits your running.
Another big mistake is buying too small. Many runners accidentally size like they’re buying casual shoes; running shoes often need a little extra space up front.
Finally, don’t assume your size is fixed across brands or models. Fit varies wildly. Treat the number on the box as a starting point, not a fact.
A simple, practical way to choose
If you want a straightforward process, do this:
- Try 2–3 shoes that match your intended use (daily training, speed, trail, etc.)
- Choose the one that disappears on your foot: no rubbing, no pinching, no sliding
- Test jog and pick the one that feels smooth and easy at your normal pace
- If you’re between two, pick the one you’re most excited to run in tomorrow
Because that’s the whole point: shoes should make it easier to run consistently.
Quick note for beginners
If you’re just starting running, shoes matter, but structure matters more. A sensible plan that builds gradually is what keeps you progressing.
If you want guidance alongside your new shoes, Runna has free training plans up to 5K (including beginner and return-to-running options) that help you build confidence without doing too much too soon.
.webp)